On Free Will

Here is a philosophical problem vis a vis Free Will:

It is either true or false that:

Every action is the result of some prior cause

If it’s true, then humans aren’t free, since every action was caused by some prior and unrelated cause. For example, although you thought that YOU raised your hand, the fact is that it went up because sounds came out of my mouth (in the form of a question), which then entered your brain, stimulated the right organs, produced the right thoughts, etc….Notice that YOU aren’t part of that chain of events.

If it’s false, then human behavior is arbitrary, since the things we do aren’t ultimately rooted in us. For example, when your hand went up, it went up because of NOTHING; that is, it just went up.

In either case, there is no freedom. We don’t have genuine free will, and as a result, cannot be praised or blamed for any moral action. Mother Teresa wasn’t so good and Hitler wasn’t that bad.

Tags:

About Ric Saenz

Ric Saenz is .........